Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders Warning

65

By Lita P.

Warning About Diagnosis

This is a warning. Do not believe or just accept your diagnosis given to you by a psychiatrist, psychologist social worker or other mental health professional. The professional could be wrong. You could be given a label that, that invites shame for you, and that can affect you, and your employment for the rest of your life. You may not even have a diagnosis. Most importantly, and something you should know is that your therapist will give you a diagnosis so they can get paid to get by an insurance company or a state funding entity. Insurance companies don’t pay for treatment if you’re just feeling sad or going through a bad time or need someone to talk to.

And sometimes just talking to someone is all that you need.

Therapists are often under contract to an HMO or state funded agency that oversees and manages psychotherapy and other health care services. Your discussions with your therapist are not totally confidential. Information about their diagnoses of you and your treatment plans are scrutinized and monitored by case managers. They become part of your permanent record.

And What About Your Diagnosis

The tool for making a mental health diagnosis is a check list of symptoms in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders ….which is written and rewritten and revised by committees composed of professionals, many, reportedly with ties to drug companies. The DSM has been revised 5 times since 1952. Homosexuality was removed in 1973 as a mental disorder in the DSM II. New diagnoses are regularly added.

The next (fifth) edition of the American Psychiatric Association's (APA) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM), commonly called DSM-5 (or, previously, DSM-V), is currently in consultation, planning and preparation. It is due for publication in May 2013 and will supersede the DSM-IV which was last revised in 2000.

According to James Maddux, professor of psychology at George Mason University, “Every time the DSM is revised it gets bigger and bigger and there seem to be more disorders and new ones seem to be invented….There has been a gradual psychopathologizing of everyday problems in living.”

You might have a problem but not a diagnosis. Your feelings might be temporary and reasonable if you consider your current circumstance.

If you’re feeling like you want to harm yourself or someone else, and have plans and means to do it; you should get help immediately.

Otherwise; don’t just accept any mental diagnosis you’re given without conducting your own further research and talking to other professionals. The person who diagnosed you might not know what the hell they’re talking about.

Comments

Wytchewoode profile image

Wytchewoode 19 months ago

Couldn't agree more ... the "psychopathologizing of everyday problems in living" simply creates problems to keep 'mental health' 'professionals' in business. 500 years ago THEY would have been witch-hunters and their 'possessed' victims tortured, mutilated and drowned or burned alive. Now they use the force of state and judicial control as legitimate reasons to drug, cut and electro-shock outsiders who do not conform to their very narrow perception of 'normality'.

Lita P. profile image

Lita P. Hub Author 19 months ago

You got it. Many are pompous, humorless tight *ssed, judgemental people who feel superior, and seem to enjoy intimidating and pushing other people around.

Not I.

Lita

schoolgirlforreal profile image

schoolgirlforreal Level 5 Commenter 19 months ago

I know this is VERY good advice. I wish I had been told, I was 16...I'm starting Lamictal now.

Anyway, this is very important to know, and I'm glad you are telling people. What do you think of Dr. Peter Breggin?

Schoolgirl4real :)

Lita P. profile image

Lita P. Hub Author 19 months ago

Wow. Thank you! I never heard of him before. I just glanced at his web site. Looks interesting. Tomorrow I'm going to his web page first thing. You have so much to offer.

Thank you so much. I have so much to learn.

Lita

L a d y f a c e profile image

L a d y f a c e 19 months ago

This is so very true. I'm so tired of hearing people say "Oh, I'm depressed." or "Sorry, I have a mental disorder" like it's a free ticket for chaos. The scope of bi-polar and depression broadens, it seems, by the day, which just serves to dilute the real issue that exists for some. I tried to help someone who said their doctor had told them they were depressed, and asked them what their signs were and what they were going through - to which they replied, "Well, I'm just sad a lot". I couldn't help myself and responded with 'that's it?'. They said '...yea why?'.

So now when someone hears that someone is bipolar or depressed or schizophrenic there's a whole NEW stigma to go along with the old faithfuls. People are taking serious meds for things they don't have. Here in Canada it's a bit different for psychiatrists, but still, they get paid based on their work, right? Psychologists however get paid by their patient here, so that's the same thing - making reasons for their patient to return. I've been to 6 different doctors since I was 12, and although 'there's a chemical imbalance in my brain' I can't help wondering if things could have been different if someone had just cared more about me instead of themselves.

It's really sad - the real face of humanity - that human beings could be so greedy as to go against their ethical code and harm others for personal gain. Makes me sick.

-sorry this was so long : /

Lita P. profile image

Lita P. Hub Author 19 months ago

I rarely use the word "depressed" because the word is so HEAVY. Maybe someone is merely sad or down, or feeling low like we all get. And maybe someone doesn't really have a MOOD DISORDER, which is a serious diagnosis. Could they just be a "touchy" or a moody person?

Thank you for your comments. They mean a lot to me.

Lita P.

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    The Emperor's New Drugs

    The Emperor's New Drugs: Exploding the Antidepressant Myth
    Amazon Price: $6.83
    List Price: $15.99
    Please wait working